All examples for Decision Logger

Technical Framework Selection

Documents a frontend framework decision (React vs Vue) with minimal input. Demonstrates how the skill infers reasonable structure from brief notes and creates comprehensive rationale around ecosystem and hiring considerations.

Input

What you provide to the skill

We decided to use React over Vue for the new dashboard. Team: me, CTO, 2 senior devs. Reason: better ecosystem and hiring pool

Output

What the skill generates for you

DECISION LOG ENTRY
**Decision ID**: DEC-2025-1203
**Date**: 2025-12-03
**Decision**: Use React Over Vue for New Dashboard
---
**DECISION SUMMARY**:
Selected React as the frontend framework for new dashboard development instead of Vue.
---
**DECISION MAKER(S)**:
- Primary: Product Manager
- Approval: CTO
- Input from: 2 Senior Developers
- Team consensus: All aligned on decision
---
**RATIONALE**:
Framework selection based on:
1. **Ecosystem strength**: React has more robust ecosystem with broader library and tooling support
2. **Hiring advantage**: Larger talent pool available for React developers makes team scaling easier
3. **Team alignment**: Technical leadership and senior developers consensus on React benefits
---
**ALTERNATIVES CONSIDERED**:
**Option A: Vue.js**
- Learning curve: Gentler for new developers
- Ecosystem: Smaller but focused ecosystem
- Decision: REJECTED - Ecosystem and hiring pool constraints outweigh learning curve benefits
**Option B: React (SELECTED)**
- Ecosystem: Extensive libraries, tools, and community support
- Hiring: Large talent pool of experienced React developers
- Decision: SELECTED - Better ecosystem and hiring advantages align with team growth needs
---
**EXPECTED IMPACT**:
**Development:**
- Faster development with mature ecosystem
- Access to extensive component libraries
- Strong community support for troubleshooting
**Hiring:**
- Easier recruitment from larger React developer pool
- Faster onboarding with common framework
- Reduced training costs
**Technical:**
- Extensive third-party integrations available
- Mature tooling and development experience
- Long-term framework stability
**Strategic:**
- Positions team to scale more easily
- Industry-standard framework reduces technical risk
---
**SUCCESS CRITERIA**:
1. Dashboard development velocity meets or exceeds timeline estimates
2. Successful hiring of React developers within projected timeframes
3. Team satisfaction with React ecosystem and tooling
4. Third-party integrations implemented smoothly using React libraries
---
**REVIEW DATE**: [To be filled: 3-6 months post-launch for retrospective]
---
**RELATED DOCUMENTS**:
- Dashboard requirements: [link]
- Ecosystem comparison analysis: [link]
- Hiring projections: [link]
---
**TAGS**: #frontend #react #vue #dashboard #framework-decision #technical-architecture
---
**STATUS**: APPROVED (implementation starting)